The task force idea sounds like a good solution. ofc, no server owner should be forced to use it, it should just replace the TyD BL (or whoever's it currently is) as the "go-to" blacklist. This way, it will avoid clan affiliations; this also entails making clan membership a non-issue when considering who to put on the task force.
As for picking the members of the task force, I believe they should be picked by the devs, and that the community shouldn't have any official impeachment powers (to avoid it being a publicity/popularity thing).
As for picking the members of the task force, I believe they should be picked by the devs, and that the community shouldn't have any official impeachment powers (to avoid it being a publicity/popularity thing).