30 Jun 10, 12:06AM
(This post was last modified: 30 Jun 10, 12:43AM by Bloodsport.)
Mael, I have watched those demos. Only the 1v1 cases are useful since in larger games, wall hacks are almost impossible to detect. I see no sign of the use of a wall hack. You regularly spam the wrong doorways and run in the wrong direction. Could you explain which of the features I mentioned in the Thorite videos you think are visible in your demos?
Thank you Thorite for at least discussing my points. In response:
Scene 1:
I am not concerned about when your aim is pointing up the stairs. I mentioned the point where you are aiming into the wall (towards the enemy), but your aim was not lined up to be looking down the corridor. I am yet to see any other player who stares into the wall while waiting for the enemy. It is much too risky, and it is far more effective to back off slightly and get a long view at a slight angle to the doorway.
Scene 2:
My point about the aim moving around is that if you believed the enemy was still in the room, you would have kept your aim still on the doorway as in other cases. However, it appears more like you are waiting for it to become clear which direction the enemy will take (through the wall). The main point of this video is your correct reaction to the opponents change in direction, not that you faced towards him while straffe running. Your explanation for the head shot is perfectly reasonable, but there are only so many times you can get lucky in one game. At 0:49 it looks to me like you back off to gain a better position (despite not yet being able to see the opponent), but then decide to go for the close shot instead. The choice of attack is not important here, it is the reaction to events out of your view.
Scene 3:
Possible, but it is too much of a coincidence that you would change direction at the point that you are facing towards him and where he is deciding between the two entrances to the RVSF base. The directness with which you exit the garage area facing to the side does not suggest the consideration of other possibilities. Taken together with the way you choose the correct direction every time makes for a compelling statistical argument.
Scene 4:
See my final responses to scene 1.
Scene 5:
Although it could by coincidence by your straffe running direction, you approximately follow the enemy's position through the wall just prior to an attack so often that it cannot always be luck. The nade you mention in the first minute is not spam, it is aimed to intercept Brain, and you get him with the second.
Scene 6:
It is extremely unlikely that you would guess the correct direction for a newly spawned enemy in this case given the number of possibilities. It is even less likely that you would choose to randomly spam with a nade since you do not do this in any other cases. You glance left while jumping out of the window despite having the opponent already in view so it is not an incorrect guess of direction. It looks more like you were having trouble getting out of the window.
Thank you Thorite for at least discussing my points. In response:
Scene 1:
I am not concerned about when your aim is pointing up the stairs. I mentioned the point where you are aiming into the wall (towards the enemy), but your aim was not lined up to be looking down the corridor. I am yet to see any other player who stares into the wall while waiting for the enemy. It is much too risky, and it is far more effective to back off slightly and get a long view at a slight angle to the doorway.
Scene 2:
My point about the aim moving around is that if you believed the enemy was still in the room, you would have kept your aim still on the doorway as in other cases. However, it appears more like you are waiting for it to become clear which direction the enemy will take (through the wall). The main point of this video is your correct reaction to the opponents change in direction, not that you faced towards him while straffe running. Your explanation for the head shot is perfectly reasonable, but there are only so many times you can get lucky in one game. At 0:49 it looks to me like you back off to gain a better position (despite not yet being able to see the opponent), but then decide to go for the close shot instead. The choice of attack is not important here, it is the reaction to events out of your view.
Scene 3:
Possible, but it is too much of a coincidence that you would change direction at the point that you are facing towards him and where he is deciding between the two entrances to the RVSF base. The directness with which you exit the garage area facing to the side does not suggest the consideration of other possibilities. Taken together with the way you choose the correct direction every time makes for a compelling statistical argument.
Scene 4:
See my final responses to scene 1.
Scene 5:
Although it could by coincidence by your straffe running direction, you approximately follow the enemy's position through the wall just prior to an attack so often that it cannot always be luck. The nade you mention in the first minute is not spam, it is aimed to intercept Brain, and you get him with the second.
Scene 6:
It is extremely unlikely that you would guess the correct direction for a newly spawned enemy in this case given the number of possibilities. It is even less likely that you would choose to randomly spam with a nade since you do not do this in any other cases. You glance left while jumping out of the window despite having the opponent already in view so it is not an incorrect guess of direction. It looks more like you were having trouble getting out of the window.