16 Jan 15, 07:42AM
I think that equal points for each judged aspect is very reasonable.
You are right that gameplay plays a key role in how players experience a map but this initial experience can vary greatly and ratings are probably gonna be biased. (1/2 WTF?!)
Quality does never result from only one criteria.
A possibility would maybe be to only rate theme, detail and gameplay while extrapoints can be given for texturing, lighting and sounds. How much extrapoints could be given at max. Should be discussed between judges (1-3?)
Other than that, count me in anyways! :)
You are right that gameplay plays a key role in how players experience a map but this initial experience can vary greatly and ratings are probably gonna be biased. (1/2 WTF?!)
Quality does never result from only one criteria.
A possibility would maybe be to only rate theme, detail and gameplay while extrapoints can be given for texturing, lighting and sounds. How much extrapoints could be given at max. Should be discussed between judges (1-3?)
Other than that, count me in anyways! :)