Current development status

[Luc@s]

Hello,

So regarding recent threads made on the forums about the development process, and some threads underlined the lack of communication. Well, this point is half-true. Indeed, we do not post very often on the forums about the recent changes. However, everyone can get the SVN, we make it so everyone can use it (binaries are compiled for you) and a changelog was even added.

So first, here is the list of changes made. It is based on the changelog with a few explanations;

Changes made from 1.1.0.4 to the trunk

Weapons

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Sniper spread reduced (60 to 50)
[*] Sniper damage set to 82
[*] Sniper ignores some armor
[*] Pistol spread reduced
[*] Pistol magsize enlarged (8 to 10)

These 5 changes are supposed to make the sniper a more competitive weapon, as it used to be in the past (especially 1.0.4 actually).
The amount of bullets needed against very-armored player was ridiculously high.
Now it will be more similar to AC 1.0.4 :
100/0 : 1 sniper shot + 1 pistol shot
100/25 : 1 sniper shot + 2 pistol shots
100/50 : 1 sniper shot + 3 pistol shots
100/75 : 1 sniper shot + 3 pistol shots
100/100 : 1 sniper shot + 4 pistol shots

This changed was brought because it was asked by many members of the community and we believed it was the right way to do it.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] SMG damage increased (15 to 16)
[*] SMG initial spread reduced
[*] SMG recoil increased

SMG was too weak in 1104, in comparison to other weapons. It was the least used weapon after carbine.
Its damage was increased a bit to make it stronger against armored players.
The recoil was increased though, making it weaker at long range than other weapons. Also, it couldn't be much stronger because the hitreg bug (which mainly affects automatic guns) is now fixed.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] AR damage reduced (24 to 22)
[*] AR kickback reduced (40 to 30)
[*] AR spread reduced
[*] AR recoil increased

The assault rifle was way too strong. Because of its impressive kickback (2.67 times as much as the SMG) and newly big magsize, and also its high damage which made it strong against armored players, it had to be weakened.
It's obviously still an interesting weapon to play, and should beats SMG at long range.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] New shotgun behavior :  3 types of rays (center, medium, outter) with different properties.

The way shotgun worked before was too simplistic and we couldn't tweak its parameters slightly. The new way it works allows finer settings.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Knife fully ignores armor

The high amount of armor on the maps made the knife weaker.
Also, maybe it's more realistic like this.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Carbine ignores some armor

Carbine was too weak (almost not used at all).

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Quicknadethrow now switches to nade even if the player was attacking.

More logical and intuitive

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Grenades accuracy, real shotgun accuracy.

Will made the approximative damage calculation scripts useless for grenades.
Also, the shotgun accuracy felt a bit weird because it could be 100 % even though only one ray hit each time. Now it's based on the "ratio rays that hit / rays fired "

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Hudgun can be displayed when spectating (and in demos - e.g. /specthudgun 1).

The question is not: "why was this implemented ?" But "why wasn't this implemented sooner ?" ;)
There were various reasons to do that, which do not only concern aesthetics. For example, it's hard to record a video of a game on some slow computers while playing. So sometimes you have to record a demo. It's way better if the video looks like it was recorded in-game.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Burst fire settings

This was available as a script but not to everyone. It's now hardcoded and everyone can use it. It can help to shot by bursts (to reduce spread, for example).
It's a kind of "guide".

Gameplay

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Votable timelimit

Sometimes you just want to vote a game for a few minutes only (e.g. in a clan match, to vote a map for 10 minutes and swap bases at intermission).
Anyway i don't see what criticisms could be done about that change.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] New gamemodes Team Last Swiss Standing / Team Pistol Frenzy

Was suggested by someone, i don't remember who.
It doesn't require much work (it's quite easy to add new modes to this game provided that they're similar to the existing ones, for example insta ctf could be added easily);

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] HTF now forces those who have the best health to pickup the flag instead of allocating it randomly

This is actually more like a bug fix, as it seemed to be the way it was supposed to work.
It was fixed after someone reported that issue on IRC (iirc).

Chat

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] New Private messages feature (/pm cn message) default bind is N

This one was suggested a few times on the forums. I can see multiple use (e.g. asking someone if he thinks another player is cheating, or talking to someone in particular w/o annoying the whole server).

Servers

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Sets kill messages to appear in log for each weapon from a config file. (Default: serverkillmessages.cfg)

It was implemented after the discussion we had on this thread : http://forum.cubers.net/thread-1218.html

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] New switch to disable game status table of scores logging. (-l switch)

Reduces server logs size; even ladder servers could turn this switch off.
I don't remember who suggested this. Maybe i decided to implement it myself.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Linux server available HDD space bug fixed.
[*] /setnext bug fixed.
Fixed bug with map names containing slashes

Bug fixes don't need explanations or justifications i think.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] The carbine is now consistently called such. (not "Rifle")

This change was supposed to fix an ambiguity issue in the code;

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] The server now differentiates between CTF/HTF scored flags in the serverlogs. (Useful for parsing/stats[ collection.)

This is a very little change, and it can be useful in some circumstances. Why shouldn't it have been done ?

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Server can restricts voting from a mode for any map

Makes it way easier to configure a server supposed to run specific gamemodes only. I think i did it after Brett told me he had to disable each mode map by map manually.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Prevent name/skin changing spam

Asked several times on the forums. It was very annoying and had to fixed.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Prevent clients from downloading the same demo twice

Some servers (especially those who are home hosted) can get laggy if one (or several) user(s) spam-download a demo.
This issue is now fixed.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Server side spawn delay check

As suggested on the forums by various members, something had to be done so as to prevent players from evading the spawn delay by reconnecting to the server.
This change also fixes a possible hack.

Server browser

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Colored ping in serverbrowser.

It might dissuade a player to join a server where his ping will be too high.
It was certainly not a waste of time to implement this since it took longer to do the commit than it took to code it.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Ability to connect to a server that requires a password via the server browser. (password protected, deban, etc.)

Asked several times on the forums.
It's more user friendly.

Media (maps/textures/models)

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Ability to download maps, textures, mapmodels on the fly when they're missing

This is a major new feature. It will allow more creativity and high quality maps with custom contents to be actually played.
We need as much feedback as possible about this feature.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] New map "ac_edifice"
[*] New map "ac_industrial"
[*] New map "ac_stellar"
[*] New map "ac_lainio"

Added after internal discussions. These maps were considered good enough to be official.
If you don't like them, don't play them. Adding them to the package was only a matter of a few more or less kilobytes.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] New map "ac_avenue"
[*] New map "ac_cavern"
[*] New map "ac_swamp"
[*] New map "ac_terros"
[*] New map "ac_venison"
[*] New map "ac_wasteland"

These maps were added because the community asked for it.
A public poll was done, and everybody was free to register his map(s).
http://forum.cubers.net/thread-6200.html[/b]

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] md2 models converted to md3

The reasons are given here : http://forum.cubers.net/thread-4444.html
md3 is a richer, more "recent" format which produces smaller files.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Many new mapmodels and textures

I don't have the list here, i wish i had it. Having more mapmodels and textures in the official packages is a plus.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Packaging reworked

The package structure had to be cleaned. A few redundant files were deleted (such as skins/textures used by several mapmodels).
The gain of file size allowed new packages to be added (hence the previous update ^)

Mapping

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Key "F7" is now key bound to toggle fullbright on/off.

Very minor change (didn't take much time) and useful yet.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Key "7" is now key bound to "nextclosestent" - it gets typo'd all the time.

same

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] entproperty now works in MP coop, but buffered.

everything that makes the coop mode closer to the offline editmode is a good thing.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Textures can now have a non-default scale, definable through the texture command.

This change is a preliminary change introducing hi-res textures.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Multiple selections support

It was suggested on the forums. It can make tedious and repetitive tasks faster to achieve. I discovered a few weeks ago that it was even in the TODO list of the first creators of the Cube engine actually.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Configurable wave height

I can't tell why it was introduced. If someone knows...
But anyway, it isn't harmful.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] newmap crash fix

/newmap 11 (or higher size) used to crash the game on some machines. It's now fixed.

Rendering / HUD / ...

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Now using ANIM_REVERSE for playermodels going backward

There was not very much to do iirc (not trying to minimize anything ;)) so it was done.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Fixed flag icon transparency.
[*] Nearplane fix.

Should i justify bug fixes ?

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] screenshotscale - in-engine scaling of screenshots.

Making the process of saving, uploading and sharing screenshots clearly makes the game more user friendly..

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] showtargetname - turns on/off showing the player name on the HUD when in your crosshair.

It was suggested on the forums. I think the reason given was that sometimes it was a pain to have it displayed while recording a video.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Scoreboard doesn't show ping/score/pj in singleplayer

"Score" is calculated by the server and unavailable in SP.
pj and ping had no reasons to be printed in single player either.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Customizable scoreboard, ability to display ratio

This was asked several times and despite many dev's concerns about re adding the ratio (including myself), it was finally implemented.
One of the reasons (i think) was that some players use modded clients just because they displayed the ratio and we'd like as many people as possible to use the official binaries. (indeed, it means they are happy with the default binaries and many don't trust those who use modded clients - and they are right!).

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Scoreboard shows the winner of each game.

It was asked in the proving grounds i think, and RR did it.
If there is a flag equality in flag modes, the game is considered as a tie.
If there is a frag equality in frag modes, the game is considered as a tie.
There was a debate on the forums about what should be looked at in case of a frag-flag equality to determine the winner.
This feature answers this question, and i strongly recommend competitive players to follow this "rule".

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] showspeed - turns speed indicator on/off

A guide for newcomers. It shows that strafe running is faster.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Improved tab completion.

I can't tell what it is, sorry.

Physics

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] New "flyspeed" variable for determining how much to multiply your fly speeds by. (Range: 1.0...5.0)

Very useful in editmode (changing gamespeed was definitely an awful way to move faster)

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Jump/Crouch raises or lowers the camera in editmode, release to stop.

Some believe that minecraft creative mode commands are more intuitive i guess.

Demos / Spectating

[*] Drop camera to previous followed player position when switching to fly specmode.
It's kinda a bug fix. It was reported on the forums.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Fix broken demo-viewer not able to change to SPECTATOR

Bug fix....

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Servers now choose a unique file name for the temporary demo file ("demorecord_<IP/local>_<port>")

Fixes a bug. (demos sometimes got corrupted because of this issue iirc).

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Hitsound while spectating

Sounds better like that ! And i think it was supposed to be like that actually.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Experimental compatibility mode for 1.1.0.4 demos

The problem came with the old tutorial. It wasn't compatible with the new version. We had different options :
#1 record a new tutorial
#2 "patch" the tutorial
#3 make the demo viewer able to read old demos

We opted for #3. But it's still experimental and maybe we should consider implementing a demo patcher instead (as an online service for example) or somethind different because we won't be able to keep the demo viewer compatible with any old demo in the future the same way it's currently done.

Sounds / Audio

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Optional heartbeat sound when health reaches a certain level.

Asked on the forums.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] New KTF score sound.

Should have been done a while ago.
Though, nobody ever suggested a specific sound iirc.......

Menus

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] New menuitems in the Keyboard menu, for looking up keybinds, and enabling/disabling the old editing binds system.

Newcomers don't know about cubescript and as many options as possible has to be settable through the menus.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] New menuitems in the gameplay settings menu, for setting fly velocities, and the color that your name is highlighted in, when it appears on the console via chat. (HIGHLIGHT)

Same as above....

Bots

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] New scripted "bot survival mode".

Interesting new bot mode where you have to stay and protect a zone as long as possible.

[SELECT ALL] Code:

[*] Bots in plclips bug fixed.
[*] Bots now actually fire the carbine.
[*] Bots can switch to, and use pistol, knife or grenades.
[*] Bots can crouch
[*] Bots have different fov, depending on their difficulty.
[*] Bot PF, LSS, Team Survivor & TOSOK modes.

1.1 Bots felt broken. It's now way funnier to play against them. They are still a bit dumb ofc but, well, try yourself !

CubeScript

Well, the cubescript changelog is quite long, and i'm not going to detail everything myself.
Although, here is the main idea :

Cubescript should allow everyone to custom their client as much as possible so as not to require modifications to the code.
Yet, it should remain as simple as possible an minimize its impact on the gameplay.
That's what we are trying to deal with. I think we're doing it right actually.
Some people criticized a few new commands, such as onHit. (which represent 0.1 % of cubescript changes) and we listened to their opinion. We also listened to those who agreed with the changes;
Don't believe that we haven't thought about it. There were internal discussions (a while before the proving grounds were set up).
We came to the conclusion that it was worth implemented these changes.
To those would criticize these changes : Are you criticizing the use of modified clients with so much spite ?

What has to be done before releasing 1200 ?

We're now sticking to bug fixes.
Here is a list of bugs that have to be fixed (some of them might already be fixed)

• major linux crash issue which is likely to be caused by the compiler we're using (from what we know ATM)
  
• texture guides don't work (another new feature recently revealed and initially discussed in the proving grounds), which was broken after the pckdownloader merge.
  
• /wpflood adds waypoints where (pl)clips already exists.
  
• Non-player initiated team changing should only occur between death and respawn
  
• Due to some issues, disallow special characters for map names
  
• Launcher asks for config.cfg file (OSX)
  
• Voicecom menu won't work? (OSX)
  

We also need more testing (i mean, we mean testing, because we nearly don't have any).

I'd like a "Beta 2" version to be released, even though the first Beta was almost not played, i hope this one will be more successful and brings more feedbacks.

Why does it take so long ?

After 1.1, a few members of the dev team left or became inactive for different reasons. The team had to be renewed and that's how many of us became devs (Bukz, me, tempest, etc.).
It took a few months :
Actually, we couldn't seriously tackle to everything we wanted at first. We were new and we looked for the "older" devs approval for most changes, because they are more experienced of course. But some of them had left and wouldn't reply to our messages. (I'm not blaming them).

Then, we started to work on the main issues : weapon balance, package downloader, and recently the anticheat.
From this point the main limiting factor was the lack of support, in any kind. Maybe we're too few. But actually, it's very hard to get testers. And testing takes time. It's a necessary step for weapon balance and ACAC;
And once you've asked Brett, or the other devs, sometimes SKB, you won't find anyone else.
We can't release something that is not tested enough. Most criticisms or feedbacks we get are about AC 1.1.

And things gets "worse and worse" : the longer we wait, the more features we add. 1200 will have taken years to come, so it's expected to be a major version, and we should provide something accordingly.
Finally, we put off the release so many times that we felt like the release date didn't matter anymore. What matters is now exclusively the quality of next release.

I'm not ignoring the fact many members of the community offered their help so as to implement new features recently. Thanks Felix the ghost, thanks the others.
Unfortunately, i think the main concern at the moment is not the lack of new features (check the changelog again, and keep in mind it's not exhaustive !).
The main concern is the few bugs remaining and the lack of testing.

Regarding violent criticisms and moderation

Moderation has always been criticized. As long as it was done in a constructive manner, it was a good thing. The same goes for the dev team.
But we cannot tolerate insults, agressive posts, or everything that is the proof of an obvious ignorance of the development status and process.
Those who can't express their opinion w/o hurting the others are not welcome here.
Inconsistent criticisms are not welcome either.
(e.g.: If you believe that the dev team is ignoring everything that is said on these forums, please prove it.)

Is there anything planned beyond 1200 ?

We have plenty of ideas for future versions, and many things are already half-done :

• A pickup/drop weapon system, which is likely to be implemented as a new gamemode (i personally think it would be better this way) (thanks VonDrakula)
  
• A auth-system
  
• make cubescript available for servers
  
• Bots available in multiplayer (new gamemodes ?)
  
• Singleplayer campaigns
  

We're also planning to report and explain more the changes we bring to the game regularly on the forums.

NB: this is not the official "dev team statement", i'm just trying to explain the current situation. I tried to be as objective as possible. However, it's possible that some devs disagree on some points

PS : i apologize for my poor English.