12 Nov 12, 08:51AM
I believe this could work, just the ability to establish the identity of a rogue player based uppon his/her interactions with others is interesting. I am not sure about the scoring, that for me would make it kind of like a popularity contest and there have been several cheats who everyone thought was a great guy and then turned out to be a cheating ass.
Until very recently I believed that very experienced players were able to tell when someone was cheating, recent events however have changed my mind I can see that even the most experienced can be sure enough to call someone as a cheat and yet it not be the case. I suspect that others would be influenced by the calls of popular or very experienced players maybe leadiing to incorrect scoring of a player.
However the identity part I am definately in favour of, the only drawback I can see is that we loose the amusement factor of the "it was my brother posts".
Until very recently I believed that very experienced players were able to tell when someone was cheating, recent events however have changed my mind I can see that even the most experienced can be sure enough to call someone as a cheat and yet it not be the case. I suspect that others would be influenced by the calls of popular or very experienced players maybe leadiing to incorrect scoring of a player.
However the identity part I am definately in favour of, the only drawback I can see is that we loose the amusement factor of the "it was my brother posts".