(18 Sep 12, 12:55AM)Cemer Wrote: on another note
why are symmetrical maps not encouraged? is it more fun to play on an asymmetric map? i think having a really well designed symmetrical map would be fun to play on
probably because nobody has made a good one. i have no idea how it would play out in AC. the other thing is a little bit of bias on each sides helps to make the gameplay more interesting, as long as the map is designed well for it. if you want a good solution towards ridiculously biased maps just make 7:30 halves in CTF and other modes(for public as well). larry did this something like 6 months ago and it didn't take him long to do.
on another note, just because a map is balanced(shine, sunset) doesn't mean it is designed well. many things on shine could be fixed to make it less bullshit, especially the ridiculous design of the mid section and akimbo/armour placement, but its still relatively even. obviously some maps are more guilty than others. desert3 however i think plays out very well, but it is hardly balanced at all. it allows for gameplay that isn't possible on other maps.
Undead Wrote:i can draw up a list of maps that have the potential for official status as well as maps that need to be changed and a vague description of what can be done about its issues.i'll do this because it seems most people just aren't sure, so i'll set something in concrete.
(18 Sep 12, 11:55AM)RAMPAGE Wrote: It's too big responsibility for just one person, and I think one person (whoever he or she is) cannot be given that power.On the other hand, group of experienced players could do the job for us.
probably because you cant fathom the responsibility yourself.