9th Endorsed Mapping Contest
#10
I think that equal points for each judged aspect is very reasonable. 

You are right that gameplay plays a key role in how players experience a map but this initial experience can vary greatly and ratings are probably gonna be biased. (1/2 WTF?!) 

Quality does never result from only one criteria.


A possibility would maybe be to only rate theme, detail and gameplay while extrapoints can be given for texturing, lighting and sounds. How much extrapoints could be given at max. Should be discussed between judges (1-3?) 




Other than that, count me in anyways! :) 
Thanks given by:


Messages In This Thread
9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 15 Jan 15, 06:00PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by MathiasB - 15 Jan 15, 08:28PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Undead - 15 Jan 15, 09:37PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Z3R0 - 15 Jan 15, 11:29PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 15 Jan 15, 11:52PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Undead - 15 Jan 15, 11:59PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 16 Jan 15, 12:00AM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Undead - 16 Jan 15, 01:31AM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Robtics - 16 Jan 15, 07:42AM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Marti - 16 Jan 15, 12:10PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Mousikos - 16 Jan 15, 04:22PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Marti - 16 Jan 15, 04:31PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Mousikos - 16 Jan 15, 10:41PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 16 Jan 15, 01:37PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Vermi - 16 Jan 15, 01:59PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 16 Jan 15, 02:11PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Undead - 16 Jan 15, 03:11PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Robtics - 16 Jan 15, 03:23PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Undead - 16 Jan 15, 03:25PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Robtics - 16 Jan 15, 03:32PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Undead - 16 Jan 15, 03:38PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Vanquish - 16 Jan 15, 09:12PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Oracle - 16 Jan 15, 09:28PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Snoosnoo - 16 Jan 15, 10:58PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Undead - 17 Jan 15, 12:38AM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 16 Jan 15, 11:22PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Snoosnoo - 17 Jan 15, 01:56AM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Undead - 17 Jan 15, 02:24AM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by ExodusS - 17 Jan 15, 02:57PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Vermi - 17 Jan 15, 11:52AM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Marti - 17 Jan 15, 12:57PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by PhaNtom - 17 Jan 15, 04:27PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Flint - 18 Jan 15, 06:50AM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 21 Jan 15, 12:59PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Alien - 21 Jan 15, 01:48PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 21 Jan 15, 01:52PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Cemer - 21 Jan 15, 10:46PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Undead - 21 Jan 15, 11:16PM
RE: 9th Official Mapping Contest - by Mousikos - 22 Jan 15, 01:04AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Undead - 22 Jan 15, 02:08AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 22 Jan 15, 01:16AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 22 Jan 15, 02:11AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Undead - 22 Jan 15, 02:38AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Vermi - 22 Jan 15, 02:17AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 22 Jan 15, 03:21AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Undead - 22 Jan 15, 03:47AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Undead - 22 Jan 15, 05:30AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Robtics - 22 Jan 15, 07:05AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Undead - 22 Jan 15, 08:31AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Undead - 22 Jan 15, 11:51AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Undead - 22 Jan 15, 12:08PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Luc@s - 22 Jan 15, 12:23PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Undead - 22 Jan 15, 12:31PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Marti - 22 Jan 15, 12:44PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Mousikos - 22 Jan 15, 02:09PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Undead - 23 Jan 15, 12:23AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Mousikos - 23 Jan 15, 04:04AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by EndGame - 22 Jan 15, 03:28PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by RKTnoob - 22 Jan 15, 04:50PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Cemer - 22 Jan 15, 11:01PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by RKTnoob - 23 Jan 15, 12:29AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 23 Jan 15, 01:17AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Undead - 23 Jan 15, 01:37AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Marti - 23 Jan 15, 03:40AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Cemer - 23 Jan 15, 07:16AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Undead - 23 Jan 15, 08:40AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 23 Jan 15, 07:43AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Marti - 23 Jan 15, 03:32PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 23 Jan 15, 03:20PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 05 Feb 15, 03:49AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Snoosnoo - 27 Feb 15, 10:41PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 27 Feb 15, 11:33PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by RKTnoob - 03 Mar 15, 06:44PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by RKTnoob - 04 Mar 15, 02:58AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 10 Mar 15, 01:45PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Robtics - 11 Mar 15, 10:18AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Mousikos - 23 Mar 15, 01:29AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Z3R0 - 24 Mar 15, 12:55AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 28 Mar 15, 04:51PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Marti - 28 Mar 15, 05:48PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 28 Mar 15, 05:50PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by RKTnoob - 28 Mar 15, 08:04PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by RKTnoob - 04 Apr 15, 09:37AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 05 Apr 15, 01:28AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 09 Apr 15, 09:51PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by MPx - 16 Apr 15, 11:22PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 21 Apr 15, 02:34AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 27 Apr 15, 12:51PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Luc@s - 28 Apr 15, 08:06AM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 04 May 15, 12:43PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 05 May 15, 12:05PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Mousikos - 05 May 15, 10:22PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 05 May 15, 10:39PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Mousikos - 05 May 15, 11:08PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 05 May 15, 11:12PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Z3R0 - 15 Aug 15, 05:35PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by yopa - 15 Aug 15, 06:16PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Luc@s - 15 Aug 15, 07:44PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by ExodusS - 15 Aug 15, 06:17PM
RE: 9th Endorsed Mapping Contest - by Pi_Halo - 18 Aug 15, 12:59PM